Homestead Rest Menu
287 items in 24 sections · $3.00 – $172.00 · Restaurant in Sparta, NJ
Homestead Rest’s menu lists 287 dishes and drinks, grouped into Appetizers, Soups & Salads, Steaks & Entrees, Legendary Burgers, Sandwiches, and Children's Menu and more. Prices range from $3.00 to $172.00, and a typical item costs about $12.00. Popular choices include Basket Of Chips, French Onion Soup, Cattle Rustler, Homestead Burger, and Gambler Cheese Steak Sandwich.
Appetizers 17
- Basket Of Chips$6.00
- Onion Rings$8.00
- French Fries$8.00
- Mozzarella Sticks$12.00
Homemade (3)
- Buffalo Shrimp (4)$16.00
Peeled shrimp in hot sauce with a side of blue cheese
- Shrimp Cocktail (5)$14.00
- Frontier Onion$12.50
Batter-dipped & deep fried, signature sauce
- Wings$14.50
Blue cheese, buffalo, honey BBQ
- Mac & Cheese$15.00
Topped with crusted cheez-its
- Palo Duro$15.00
Nachos, Cheddar & mozzarella cheese, chopped tomatoes, pickled jalapenos, black olives, sour cream, salsa
- Tater Skins$12.00
Homemade, bacon, Cheddar and sour cream
- Mexican Bullets$10.00
Jalapeño poppers served with sour cream & salsa
- Homestead Guacamole$10.00
Served with house tortilla chips
- Sweet Potoato Fries$10.00
- Veggie Side$5.00
- Mashed Potatoes$5.00
- Baked Potato$3.00
Soups & Salads 6
- French Onion Soup$7.00
Bowl
- Homestead Chili$10.00
Bowl
- Soup Of The Day$6.00
Bowl
- The Lonesome Dove Salad$7.00
Our signature Caesar salad
- Homestead Garden Salad$7.00
Fresh chopped romaine, sliced carrots, cherry tomatoes, red cabbage, cucumbers and choice of dressing
- The Southwest Cowboy Salad$14.00
Romaine lettuce, red onion, chopped tomatoes, bacon, avocado, manchego cheese, chili-cilantro-lime vinaigrette
Steaks & Entrees 8
- Cattle Rustler$48.00
16 oz boneless ribeye. Our premium steaks are seasoned with salt and pepper and grilled to perfection with a touch of melted butter and parsley. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and s
- Rodeo Chicken$22.00
Boneless breast, provolone cheese, ham, tomatoes, mushrooms, sherry-cream sauce. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Chicken Spurs$20.00
All natural chicken strips floured, crispy fried and served with vegetables and homemade honey mustard sauce. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Peco's Shrimp$28.00
Fried shrimp with cocktail sauce. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Beer Battered Fish & Chips$20.00
Atlantic cod fish, classic tartar sauce. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Grilled Salmon$23.00
Seasoned & grilled choice of honey ginger glaze or lemon-dill sauce. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Fajitas$22.00
Salsa, sour cream, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, black olives and shredded cheddar cheese. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
- Buffalo Shrimp$28.00
Fried shrimp tossed in hot sauce with blue cheese dressing. Comes with a side salad and a choice of baked or mashed potatoes, fries or homemade chips and seasonal vegetables
Legendary Burgers 2
- Homestead Burger$18.00
1/2 pound of our proprietary blend of premium ground beef grilled, beef with homemade chips or crispy fries, American, Cheddar, or Swiss cheese. A Sussex County Legend. Cheese, bacon, sauteed onions & mushrooms
- The Max Burger$17.00
1/2 pound of our proprietary blend of premium ground beef grilled, beef with homemade chips or crispy fries, American, Cheddar, or Swiss cheese. Cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, & onions
Sandwiches 9
- Gambler Cheese Steak Sandwich$24.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Sliced ribeye steak, cheese, mushrooms, peppers & onions
- Gun Smok'n Chicken Sandwich$15.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Fried chicken breast, hot sauce, blue cheese dressing
- Cheese Quesadillas$15.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Cheddar cheese, fried onions, salsa, jalapeños, tomatoes, black olives & sour cream
- Chili & Chips$15.00
Chili, Cheddar cheese, chopped onions, jalapenos, black olives, salsa, sour cream
- Buffalo Bill Sandwich$14.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard sauce
- Stockyard BLT Sandwich$12.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, on Texas toast
- Quarter Horse Wrap$14.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries. Grilled chicken with our own Caesar salad in a wrap
- The Reiner Grilled Cheese Sandwich$12.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries
- Saloon Style Fish Fillet Sandwich$17.00
Served with a choice of homemade chips or crispy fries
Children's Menu 4
- Kids-Hot Dog + Fries$5.00
- Kids-Hamburger + Fries$7.00
- Kids-Mac & Cheese$6.00
- Kids-Chicken Spurs + Fries$8.00
Desserts 6
- Homemade Rice Pudding (Our Specialty) Copy$8.00
- Homemade Carrot Cake Copy$10.00
- Homemade Chocolate Reese's Peanut Butter Cake Copy$10.00
- Homemade Pumpkin Pie Copy$8.00
- Ice Cream Copy$8.00
- Key Lime Pie Copy$8.00
N/A Beverages 15
- Coffee$3.00
- Tea$3.00
- RC$4.00
- Diet RC$4.00
- Sprite$4.00
- Ginger Ale$4.00
- Shirley Temple$5.00
- Juice$4.00
- Milk$4.00
- Chocolate Milk$5.00
- Cappuccino$6.00
- Ice Tea$4.00
- Hot Chocolate$4.00
- Espresso$5.00
- Lemonade$4.00
Daily Specials-Appetizers 2
- "Disco Fries"$12.00
Potato wedges topped with mozzarella cheese, crispy bacon and homemade gravy
- Our Special Wings$15.00
Baked seasoned wings that are fried and tossed in a buffalo BBQ sauce served with a side of spicy ranch dip
Daily Specials- Soup 1
- Chicken Orzo Soup$100.00
Daily Specials- Entrees 5
- New York Strip Steak$38.00
Served blackened and topped with crumbled feta cheese served with choice of potato, vegetable of the day and a side salad
- Open Style Roast Beef Sandwich$24.00
Thinly sliced roast beef on Texas toast topped with homemade gravy served with a side of mashed potatoes, vegetable of the day and a side salad
- Classic Turkey Burger$16.00
Turkey burger topped with melted Swiss cheese and sweet fig on a brioche bun served with choice of homemade chips or fries
- Italian Style Chicken Sandwich$18.00
Crispy chicken topped with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce on a hero roll served with choice of homemade chips or fries
- "Mac & Cheese Burger"$18.00
Our classic burger topped with creamy mac & cheese and crispy bacon on a brioche bun served with choice of homemade chips or fries
Daily Specials- Desserts 6
- Homemade Rice Pudding (Our Specialty)$8.00
- Homemade Carrot Cake$10.00
- Homemade Chocolate Reese's Peanut Butter Cake$10.00
- Homemade Pumpkin Pie$8.00
- Ice Cream$8.00
- Key Lime Pie$8.00
Cocktail Specials *MISSING PRICING* 9
- Pink Pony Club$12.00
Vodka, strawberry pomegranate juice, lime juice, club
- Prime Time Old Fashioned Smash$12.00
Bourbon, strawberry pomegranate juice, eucalyptus bitters, orange peel
- Coco Lime Cow$12.00
Coconut rum, cream of coconut, lime juice, club soda
- Cucumber Mint Gin Fizz$12.00
Gin, muddled cucumbers and mint, fresh lime juice, club soda
- Sweet Cherry Pie-Tini$12.00
Vodka, black cherry juice, amaretto, lemon juice
- Hot Hogin$12.00
Tequila, strawberry pomegranate juice, hot honey, club
- Upside-Down Pineapple Cake$12.00
Rum, pineapple juice, grenadine
- On The Range Paloma$12.00
Gin, strawberry pomegranate juice, lime juice, club soda
- Wrangler Margarita$12.00
Tequila, St. Germain, fresh pear juice, lime juice, blue agave
Cocktails 37
- Alabama Slammer$13.00
- Appletini$12.00
- Bahama Mama$12.00
- Baybreeze$10.00
- Black Russian$12.00
- Bloody Mary$11.00
- Cape Cod$10.00
- Chocolate Martini$14.00
- Cosmo$14.00
- Daiquiri$12.00
- Espresso Martini$15.00
- French Martini$14.00
- Fuzzy Navel$12.00
- Gibson$11.00
- Gimlet$11.00
- Golden Cadillac Margarita$14.00
- Irish Coffee$14.00
- Kahlua + Cream$13.00
- Lemon Drop$14.00
- Long Island Tea$12.00
- Madras$12.00
- Mai Tai$12.00
- Malibu Baybreeze$12.00
- Manhattan$12.00
- Margarita$12.00
- Martini$14.00
- Mimosa$12.00
- Mojito$12.00
- Moscow Mule$12.00
- Mudslide$12.00
- Nutty Irishmen$12.00
- Old Fashion$12.00
- Tequila Sunrise$12.00
- Tom Collins$11.00
- Virgin Mary$11.00
- Whiskey Sour$12.00
- White Russian$12.00
Brandy/Cognac 2
- Brandy$10.00
- Hennessey$16.00
Bourbon/Whiskey 56
- 1792 Bourbon$13.50
- Angels Envy$15.00
- Belle Meade$13.00
- Black Dirt$14.00
- Basil Bourbon$14.00
- Basil Rye$14.00
- Blantons$19.00
- Blantons Bourbon$16.00
- Bourbon$11.00
- Buffalo Trace$17.00
- Bullet Bourbon$14.00
- Bullet Rye$14.00
- Charles Gnight Bourbon$17.00
- Crown Royal$13.00
- Crown Vanilla$14.00
- Dad's Hat$13.00
- Dead Rabbit$14.00
- Eagle Rare Bourbon$17.00
- Fighting 69$13.00
- Fireball$10.00
- Hellcat Maggie$13.00
- High West Bourbon$12.50
- High West Double Rye$12.50
- High West 175 Bottle$73.00
- High West 375 Bottle$26.00
- High West 750 Bottle$40.00
- High West Midwinter$172.00
- High West Old Fashion$30.00
- High West Rendezvous$99.00
- Hudsons$13.00
- Jack Daniels$13.00
- Jack Fire$13.00
- Jack Honey$13.00
- Jack Apple$13.00
- Jameson$13.00
- Jeffersons$15.00
- Jim Beam$11.00
- Kentucky Vintage$14.00
- Knob Creek$13.00
- Legent$13.00
- Maker's Mark$14.00
- Mitchers Bourbon$13.00
- Mitchers Rye$13.00
- Old Granddad$11.00
- Telmore Dew$14.00
- Uncle Nearest 1856$12.00
- VO$11.00
- Westland$15.00
- Whiskey$11.00
- Whistle Pig$16.00
- Wild Turkey$11.00
- Willet$16.00
- Woodford Dbl Oak$19.00
- Woodford Reserve$16.00
- Yellowstone$14.00
- Yukon Jack$11.00
Gin 6
- Beefeater$11.00
- Bombay Sapphire$14.00
- Gin$11.00
- Hendricks$13.00
- Hendricks Lunar$14.00
- Tanqueray$13.00
Liqueur/Schnapps 28
- 43$11.00
- Amaretto Sour$10.00
- Anisette$10.00
- Aperol$11.00
- Apple Pucker$9.00
- B&B$12.00
- B52$12.00
- Bailey's Irish Creme1$11.00
- Black Haus$10.00
- Blackberry$9.00
- Cafe Patron$14.00
- Campari$10.00
- Chambord$10.00
- Cointreau$14.00
- Creme De Cocoa$9.00
- Creme De Mint$9.00
- Cynar$7.00
- Disaronno$12.00
- Frangelico$11.00
- Godiva$12.00
- Grand Marnier$14.00
- Jagermesier$13.00
- Kahlua$12.00
- Lemon Cello$11.00
- Midori$11.00
- Mr Black$12.00
- Toasted Almond$11.00
- White Chocolate Liquor$11.00
Rum 5
- Bacardi$12.00
- Captain Morgan$12.00
- Malibu$11.00
- Myer's Dark Rum$12.00
- Tia Maria$11.00
Scotch 20
- Balvenie 12 Yr$17.00
- Balvenie 15 Yr$22.00
- Chivas Regal$13.00
- Cutty Sark$11.00
- Dalmore Single Malt$13.00
- Dalmore 12 Yr$17.00
- Dalmore 15 Yr$22.00
- Dewars$12.00
- Drambuie$11.00
- Glenlivet 12 Yr$14.00
- Glenfiddich 12 Yr$15.00
- Glenlivet 15 Yr$17.00
- Johnny Walker Black$15.00
- Johnny Walker Blue$55.00
- Johnny Walker Red$13.00
- Johnny Drum$14.00
- Macallan 12 Yr$17.00
- Macallan 15 Yr$22.00
- Macallan 18 Yr$57.00
- Macallan 21 Yr$102.00
Tequila 20
- 1800$13.50
- Ayote Anejo$17.00
- Casa Azul$35.00
- Casa Noble$14.00
- Casamigos$12.00
- Codgio$14.00
- Corazon Blanco$12.00
- Cuervo Gold$11.00
- Don Julio$17.00
- Espolon$13.00
- Herradura$15.00
- Jose Cuervo$11.00
- La Adelita$18.00
- Mi Campo Reposado$12.00
- Mi Campo Silver$12.00
- Mijenta$14.00
- Montezuma$11.00
- Tequila$11.00
- Tequila 1800$14.00
- Tequila Gold$11.00
Vodka 8
- Absolute$11.00
- Belvedere$15.00
- Grey Goose$14.00
- Grey Goose Orange$14.00
- Kettle One$14.00
- Tito's$12.00
- Vodka$11.00
- Vanilla Vodka$11.00
Wine 7
- House Cab$9.00
- House Merlot$9.00
- Pinot Noir$9.00
House Pinot Noir
- House Chardonnay$9.00
- Pinot Grigio$9.00
House Pinot Grigio
- House Sauvignon Blanc$9.00
- Prosecco$10.00
Draft Beer 8
- Blue Moon$7.00
- Yuengling$6.00
- Sam Seasonal$7.00
- Cider$7.00
- Guinness$8.00
- Stella Artois$7.00
- Birch Beer$5.00
- IPA Special$8.00
How these prices compare
Based on 109 menus with 8,058 priced items from restaurants in New Jersey, the median menu item costs $14.15, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $20.00.
At Homestead Rest the median listed price is $12.00, lower than the typical $14.15 for restaurants in New Jersey.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Onion Rings | $8.00 | $8.70 |
| French Fries | $8.00 | $6.45 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $12.00 | $12.00 |
| Coffee | $3.00 | $3.00 |
Typical prices are calculated from 109 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.